The Whole Enchilada: Screening The Entire Donor List

What does “donor research” and “wealth-screening” mean to you?

This three-part series examines the latest in donor research in three critical areas:

1. The value of screening your entire donor database;
2. Tips on what’s new about wealth screening so that you can “sell” it; and
3. The value of relationship science to connect with donors.

Part I: The Whole Enchilada: Screening the Entire Donor List

Have you wealth-screened your entire donor database? If you were like me when I served as the director of development at a local nonprofit, the answer is “No.” I only screened those select individuals I deemed to be “major donors,” and my screening methods (Google, looking at real-estate assets, considering a donor’s profession, etc.) were limited at best. I was defeating the entire purpose of prospect research in the first place—to tell me something I didn’t know about my donors, namely, that they might have the capacity to give more than I ever imagined. I like to use the analogy of “finding the needle in the haystack.” You see, the problem with only screening major donor prospects is that, on average, we are leaving 80% of our database untouched. When we “batch wealth-screen” our entire donor database, we can do five things we couldn’t do before:

1. Accurately evaluate major donor prospects.
2. Identify strong annual-fund givers, monthly givers, and planned giving prospects.
3. Find hidden major donors among your annual-fund givers and cultivate them.
4. Segment your mail list so that donors receive appropriate appeals.
5. Ask for increased gifts through moves management.

Michael welcomes your feedback about your experiences with wealth screening. May we hear from you on our blog?

Related Posts

Foundations Aren’t Much Interested in You

“America’s foundations are not particularly interested in receiving your proposal.” – Bradford K. Smith, President of Candid

Grateful for Brad Smith’s candor and leadership over the years, I rang him up for a chat. Initially, I wanted to know if what our grant officers suspected was in fact true—that most foundations do not welcome your proposals.

Read More »

Virtual Parties With A Purpose: A Compliment to Large Galas

Do you want to throw small virtual fundraising events? If so, this blog post is for you. Big galas have their place, but smaller online events can be impressively lucrative when done well. Sometimes called “Parlor Gatherings,” we call them “Parties with a Purpose” (PWAP). These events can complement your large gala—or even be held in lieu of it.

Read More »

Your Questions, Our Answers on Starting Over with Individual Donors

The questions below were asked by attendees at our “Starting Over” webinar of April 21, 2021, presented by Roger Craver & Laurence A. Pagnoni.

The questions are fascinating, and we hope you’ll find our answers equally so. The webinar focused on the new rules of individual giving fundraising. We welcome your input as well by posting on our blog.

Read More »

Let Your Donors Know – 2021 Tax Incentives

Here are SPECIAL 2021 TAX INCENTIVES FOR GIVING for you to let your donors know. Congress has provided several economic incentives to help address the far-reaching effects of the COVID-19 pandemic, including additional tax incentives to encourage charitable giving. These incentives are temporary and are scheduled to expire at the end of 2021.

Read More »