Giving Tuesday vs. Donor Advised Funds

By Laurence A. Pagnoni, MPA

As Giving Tuesday comes around on November 30, I am asking you to think deeply before you commit to promoting it.

My annual struggle over whether to include Giving Tuesday (GT) in my year-end fundraising plan is in full swing.

This year, I am distracted by the gargantuan untapped revenue that you can access from those donors with Donor Advised Funds (DAFs) — upwards of $140 billion. I am asking myself if instead of focusing on Giving Tuesday, would it be more lucrative for me to focus on cultivating and soliciting those donors with Donor Advised Funds?

Your Decision

Don’t get me wrong, I am a fan of Giving Tuesday, but only when it’s a lucrative tactic among your other fundraising approaches. For many nonprofits, the means does not justify the ends.

You should consider skipping GT, especially if you have other parts of your year-end giving program designed and ready to launch, and most especially if your social media platforms are not what they could be. I parse out the reasons for and against here.

But even if you are all in on GT, DAFs also deserve your attention.

The nonprofit sector goes silly over Giving Tuesday. Yet all that effort, time and clamor raised $800 million last year. By comparison, tapping just a meager 1% of the $140 billion available today in DAFs would produce $1.4 billion!

See why I am asking you to think deeply about whether GT is right for you?

I suspect many of us gravitate to GT because it’s easier to implement.

Finding DAF’s requires more effort. How do we find out who has a DAF? How do we research who has DAFs when there’s no public information about them?

Here are three steps to take to secure DAF funds:

1. Install the DAF Widget at Your Website

The DAF Direct Widget is the place to start.  This widget plugs into three of the largest DAF managers: Fidelity, Schwab, and Bank of New York. These providers account for a large chunk of DAF money and their minimums make for great prospects.  When you have the widget on your site or donation page, not only does it take someone to their account, it is restricted so that person can give only to you.

You can download the Widget here. (You can also check out this excellent FAQ). It costs nothing. All you’ll need is your nonprofit’s 501c(3) Tax ID number.

2. Start Surveying Your Donors

Are you surveying your donors and asking them how they prefer to make their contributions? That’s a good way to find out if they have a DAF. On your list of boxes to check about how they want to give, include a check box for DAFs. You can find a sample donor survey here.

3. Get Serious About Prospect Research

I am often impressed with how much development officers know about their donors. But the fact is a lot of information about a donor’s capacity to give is hidden. Advanced donor research can surface that crucial information for you and determine their propensity to give.

The hidden information is especially relevant when you are seeking transformational gifts — gifts that cover multiple years, are made in exchange for naming opportunities, and grow your reserves.

The advanced research I am talking about allows you to have a more informed conversation with your donors. While you need deep research in order to close on the highest gifts possible, getting that data is time consuming and complicated.

Worse, data vendors usually overwhelm you with more information than is actionable.

In the case of one LAPA client, their initial reservations evaporated after we completed our research. We found 373 hidden major donor prospects just within her own donor database—and 47 of them were donor advised fund holders! At the end of the research process actionable engagement plans were appended directly to their donor base, and the donor cultivation steps were scheduled in her calendar. Now, that nonprofit is a believer.

Oh, I almost forgot! We found an additional 3,500 new value-aligned donors that were then added to their donor pipeline. Finding new donors is the holy grail of fundraising. Advanced Prospect Research produces the highest quality donor data at several levels. I explain more here in this white paper about advanced donor research.

If you’d like to talk through where you are with these three steps, contact Brooke Bryant, CFRE, our Managing Director.

What is your thinking about this year’s Giving Tuesday? What do you think of my three recommendations? Please let me know by commenting below.

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Related Posts

Does positive or negative messaging raise more funds?

Do Negativity and Alarm Really Raise Funds?

By Laurence A. Pagnoni, MPA A reader writes: “My inbox and mailbox are flooded with fundraising appeals from causes using the words ‘terrifying,’ ‘alarming,’ ‘emergency,’ etc.  “Yes, we’re in deep sh*t on many levels. Why would they think I don’t know this? The messages only make me more depressed, and depression does not motivate me to contribute. Does negativity and alarm really raise funds?”  —John, CEO of a civic education nonprofit   Dear John, This is a top-of-mind question for many fundraising professionals. Fundraisers use danger messages because marketing data often (not always) shows they’re highly effective when compared with

Read More »
Use this touchpoints as loudspeakers to maximize donor engagement.

7 Key Touchpoints to Keep Donors Engaged

By Alexa Strautmanis Seven is a golden number in marketing. As the “Rule of Seven” goes, an individual must see or interact with your nonprofit’s brand at least seven times in the course of a year before they’re inclined to take any action.  Following this rule is a best practice when it comes to donor engagement. Through multichannel marketing, these seven touches can be seamlessly woven into your nonprofit’s communications to keep your cause top-of-mind for new donors and deepen relationships with your current supporters. Your nonprofit may already be hitting this magic number. If you mail your constituents quarterly,

Read More »

Private Grants: Are They for You?

Six steps to making a grants assessment. By Laurence A. Pagnoni, MPA and Sheldon Bart Here’s a tale of two real nonprofits. Let’s call the first one Amazing Youth, and the second The Real Deal Healthcare. Amazing Youth operates a transitional shelter for homeless youth limited by law to a modest number of residents, fewer than 10. The Real Deal Healthcare operates a community health center serving thousands of low-income patients. Both are LAPA clients. What they have in common is that for many years both neglected private grant revenue. Eventually, each one came to understand the value of outsourcing

Read More »

Our 2022 Crystal Ball

By Brooke Bryant, Ph.D; Robin Merle, CFRE; and Laurence A. Pagnoni, MPA As we approach a new year, fundraisers continue to navigate an unsettled landscape. The ongoing COVID-19 pandemic, calls for racial justice, changing donor expectations, and a tight labor market have been central themes in 2021 — and they will continue to influence how we approach our work in 2022. Against that backdrop, we offer these 12 fundraising trends to watch over the next 12 months: The 12 Biggest Nonprofit Trends for 2022 Donors Will Give More Generously Equity Must Be Front and Center Hybrid Is Here to Stay Megadonors Will Be

Read More »