Private Grants: Are They for You?

Six steps to making a grants assessment.

By Laurence A. Pagnoni, MPA and Sheldon Bart

Here’s a tale of two real nonprofits. Let’s call the first one Amazing Youth, and the second The Real Deal Healthcare.

Amazing Youth operates a transitional shelter for homeless youth limited by law to a modest number of residents, fewer than 10.

The Real Deal Healthcare operates a community health center serving thousands of low-income patients. Both are LAPA clients.

What they have in common is that for many years both neglected private grant revenue. Eventually, each one came to understand the value of outsourcing their grants program.

They realized that their best option was to depend on an experienced LAPA consultant to research and identify funding prospects, then compose and submit proposals, applications, letters of intent, and grant reports required to secure renewal funding. The outsourcing increased revenues. It also allowed their respective executive staffs to concentrate on their respective core competencies. (Learn more about our Grants & Evaluation Services.)

Amazing Youth, a LAPA client for 12 years, is approaching $2 million in grants secured.

The Real Deal Healthcare, operating on a larger scale, has exceeded $1 million in grants secured within only 2.5 years. Its CEO, a dynamic woman, upon hitting this milestone, said to us, “I remember you all told us that it would take a few years, but, boy, the work has really paid off.”

Many nonprofits like Amazing Youth depend on a government contract and sputtering special events, with limited individual donor support.

Others, like The Real Deal Healthcare, sustain themselves on fees; federal, state, and municipal money; and well-done galas. In previous times, they both were lackadaisical about private grants.

Yet, if they have the program-impact metrics, private and corporate grant awards can increase their revenue by multiple hundreds of thousands of dollars annually. Over time, these awards can mount into eye-popping sums.

How Can You Tell if It’s Worth It for You?

The short answer is that you must conduct an assessment right from the start; some fundraisers call them desk studies. The assessment is aimed at answering one core question: What is this revenue stream worth to us, if done well? Such a study is centered on upfront research. Here are the steps:

  1. Do a Reverse Search: Go to the Foundation Directory and do a reverse search on your own nonprofit. The information that surfaces may go back more than 10 years. You’re therefore likely to find a number of foundations that have made grants to your organization in the past but have not been contacted recently.The amount of the prior award(s) may be low because no one has asked the grant-maker(s) to give at a higher rate. You now have a list of lapsed funders. Check their websites for current deadlines and geographic and funding priorities. Note those that have remained aligned with your organization and its mission.
  2. Search Under Multiple Categories: Let’s say your agency is a faith-based organization that operates shelter and addiction treatment services in Yonkers, N.Y. This gives you five categories to search for more prospective foundation supporters: grant-makers giving to your particular faith; shelter and housing funders; funders interested in substance abuse; funders based in Yonkers or giving to nonprofits that serve Yonkers; and, of course, human services. Search under all these categories.
  3. Secure Essential Information: A spreadsheet will prove useful for storing the information you bring up. Capture the name of each foundation; note the suggested ask amount; check the funder’s 990 and/or website; and make your best guesstimate of the amount of money it may realistically award your nonprofit. Then assess the probability of securing that grant. We rate foundations on a scale ranging from high probability of securing a grant to medium, low, and speculative. “Speculative” means least likely. Also note any deadlines. Record peculiarities of the grant-making process (“Call first to discuss,” “Send LOI,” “Gives for human services in areas of company operations”); whether they make awards for general support or equipment; or any other pertinent tidbit (“Primarily interested in alcoholism,” “Committed until 2022”).Be sure to note how you found the prospect, so you can fish it up again later (“Roman Catholic funder,” “Based in Yonkers”).
  4. Assess Competitors: The final research step involves a reverse search of one of your keenest competitors. Select a thriving agency that provides similar services, and see what turns up. Some new funding prospects for your organization will likely emerge.
  5. Estimate the ask: Now add your lapsed funders to the spreadsheet and the foundations that have supported your competitor and are new to you. Carefully label them in the notes section as “lapsed” or “XYZ funder.” The analytical process is purely a matter of common sense. List the prospects that you’ve rated as highly likely to give or medium likely and, next to each one, the suggested ask. Add up the amount of money you estimate receiving.
  6. Check Funding Location: Consider also where you’re located. More than a third of the 50 states have fewer than 40 nonprofits for every 10,000 residents. Local fundraising is consequently more competitive for nonprofits in these states. Knowledge of out-of-state funders is imperative to score more awards, but only if they fund in your area.
  7. Make the Cost/Benefit Analysis: Naturally, you’re not going to score with every potential funder. But what would 30% of the total look like? What amount of revenue would you secure if only 25% of the grant-makers on the final list made an award?

If you would come away with, say, $200,000 if only one-quarter of the funders on the final list approved a grant, can you really afford to pass up this revenue?

Please let us know what the state of your private grants program is and your experience in doing this work in the comment area below.


Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Related Posts

Create An Impact Report That Shows Donors Your Value

By Laurence A. Pagnoni, MPA A growing number of nonprofits are creating impact reports to show donors how their contributions have made a difference. When done well, impact reports can be powerful tools for showing results through hard numbers. But they truly excel when they amplify the metrics with real-life stories and voices that put a face on the organization’s work. The Massachusetts nonprofit Root Cause married numbers and stories beautifully with its recently released Impact Report: 2021. This piece is especially effective because it provides a clear snapshot of what the organization does, uses simple graphics to display information,

Read More »

Three Steps to Manage Uncomfortableness in Fundraising

By Laurence A. Pagnoni, MPA We try our utmost to avoid it, but feeling uncomfortable is key to fundraising mastery. In fact, the more advanced fundraising you seek, the more uncomfortable feelings rise. Yet it is an enormous (and lucrative) gift to yourself, and especially to your nonprofit, to work through these initial feelings. Aversion for being uncomfortable is understandable. Uncomfortable situations trigger feelings of being out of control. Anxiety and fear storm through us and our bodies get tense. Being uncomfortable goes against our innate desire to feel calm and at peace. Many fundraisers call me when they are

Read More »

Do You Report Back After Donors Are Surveyed?

By Laurence A. Pagnoni, MPA. Your survey to donors is only half the picture. You have to report back your findings. In this blog post, we are modeling for you how to report back, so that you in turn can do the same with your donors. You see, hundreds of LAPA’s 70,000+ blog readers and webinar attendees recently took an Audience Survey on their experiences of using our thought-leadership content—our weekly blog post, our webinars, our white papers, and sample cases for support, and Laurence’s books. Here’s what they said. You can use our format to report back to your

Read More »

Behold, the Carbon Neutral Direct Mail Campaign!

By Roger M. Craver, JD. Last week, we celebrated Earth Day, which makes it an appropriate time for fundraisers to think about what we’re really doing — professionally, personally, and collectively — to save our planet. I’m not asking you to think about raising money for climate change or conservation. Instead, it’s time to consider how our practices are affecting our planet — and how we can take collective actions at our organizations to make a difference. In gathering my ball of string for this Earth Day post, I came across a LinkedIn post from Steve Falk, President and CEO of Canada’s Prime Data.

Read More »