Advancing Your Prospect Research

By Laurence A. Pagnoni, MPA

A lot of donor information is hidden. Most donors aren’t advertising their net worth or telling us about the other nonprofits they donate to.

So it’s up to us to do the research in advance of our conversations with them.

Three Options

Nonprofits have three options for conducting this research:

  • Conducting In-House Research — Larger nonprofits with the financial means often build dedicated research teams into their organizational structure.
  • Hiring a Consultant — Instead of hiring a full-time prospect researcher or having an existing staff member screen donors, you can bring in consultants like LAPA Fundraising to take the lead.
  • Enlisting a Screening Company — Screening companies can compare thousands of donors against various major databases and help you rank your prospects according to potential.

The Art of Knowing What to Do with the Donor Data

Many nonprofits invest in donor research services that promise to deliver insights about their donors that are not in public view.

Unfortunately, these data vendors overwhelm you with information that is not actionable.

Advanced prospect research cuts through this noise by identifying the most relevant donor data and marrying this information with your cultivation and solicitation path. (We will show you how to use advanced prospect research to increase revenue at our free webinar on June 15 at 11 a.m. ET. Register now. I hope you’ll join us).

Knowing what to do with your donor data is the real art of advanced fundraising. That is usually outside the scope of service of the vendor who sold you the data, but it is of central concern to fundraisers.

Understanding Charitable Giving Indicators

Through years of experience, I’ve learned which data points are most instructive in gauging a donor’s capacity and willingness to give.

We have identified more than 100 indicators. Here are just the top ones:

  • Giving to Other Nonprofits — Donors who give $100,000 or more to at least one nonprofit are 32 times more likely to make a similarly-sized donation elsewhere than the average person.
  • Political Giving — Donors who have given more than $2,500 in federal election contributions and charitable giving are 14 times more likely to donate.
  • Real Estate Ownership — Donors who own real estate valued at more than $2 million are 17 times more likely to engage in philanthropy.

These indicators will help you know which of your current donors are more likely to support your organization at a higher level. They can also help you identify new prospective donors.

Segmenting Your Donors

You should create donor segments. Your donors can be segmented into the following categories:

  • Transformational donors
  • Major donors
  • Annual fund donors
  • “Bread and butter” donors

The criteria for these segments differ from nonprofit to nonprofit — and each of these segments are refined as we conduct further research. Some nonprofits have more than 100 donor segments.

These segments help you better understand the motivation behind each donor group and, in turn, develop tailored campaigns.

You can also use the insights gained through advanced prospect research to prioritize and segment prospective donors — and build relationship maps (RelSci), which allow you to find the fastest path to connect.

Secure Higher Gifts

Prospect research generates donor data that allows you to efficiently surface and solicit donors at every level. You will know the size of the donations to request, or at least the range of past giving, so you’re not asking for more or less than the individual’s capacity to give.

This advanced knowledge increases your likelihood of securing higher gifts.

All of this fuels your organizational growth — allowing you to fulfill your mission.

By investing in advanced prospect research, your nonprofit will have the resources to truly make a significant impact.

What’s your experience with prospect research? Please share this post with a colleague who may appreciate it.

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Related Posts

New ‘Giving USA’ Report Signals Turbulence Ahead for Fundraisers

By Laurence A. Pagnoni, MPA The pre-eminent source of annual data about giving and philanthropy in the United States — Giving USA Foundation — this week released its 2021 report. This year’s edition offers a mixed bag of news for fundraisers and sends a few warning signals about what we can expect in the balance of 2022. But before the warnings, some good news: Charitable giving totaled a near-record $484.9 billion in 2021, which was flat when compared to 2020. That’s considered a win, especially since COVID-19 sparked an 8.1% annual increase in giving in 2020, and many observers feared

Read More »

Have You Received Charitable Donations From Russian Oligarchs?

By Laurence A. Pagnoni, MPA Over the past two decades, hundreds of U.S. nonprofits have received massive philanthropic support from Russia’s superwealthy, often celebrated with named scholarships and buildings. Yet within the nonprofit sector, there is little conversation about this. In light of the horrific war that has been unleashed on Ukraine, do you wish to continue to steward and receive their support? Today we ask, “What are your policies and procedures for receiving Russian megagifts — and megagifts overall?” I hope that this blog, and the research we’re sharing, will foster a discussion within your nonprofit that will help

Read More »

Should Your Fundraising Be Apolitical?

By Laurence A. Pagnoni, MPA Nonprofits involved with the abortion debate are seeing a fundraising spike because of the recent leak of a draft opinion by the U.S. Supreme Court that would overrule Roe v. Wade. But for nonprofits whose missions are not about reproductive rights, the future of Roe v. Wade is causing intense internal discussions about whether they should take a stand or be apolitical. The topic of abortion stirs strong emotions on both the left and right. As a result, public statements from a nonprofit on the issue are likely to rankle a portion of its donor base.

Read More »

Create An Impact Report That Shows Donors Your Value

By Laurence A. Pagnoni, MPA A growing number of nonprofits are creating impact reports to show donors how their contributions have made a difference. When done well, impact reports can be powerful tools for showing results through hard numbers. But they truly excel when they amplify the metrics with real-life stories and voices that put a face on the organization’s work. The Massachusetts nonprofit Root Cause married numbers and stories beautifully with its recently released Impact Report: 2021. This piece is especially effective because it provides a clear snapshot of what the organization does, uses simple graphics to display information,

Read More »